Pinpricks of ice pelt my cheeks as I stumble my way to Miriam’s massive front door. Gloved fingers brushing the spiky sprigs of a cedar wreath, I take hold of the door knocker, dropping the brass ball with one solid thunk, followed by another. My nostrils sting with each inhale, my breath pulsing between my lips in wraith-like tendrils.
Everleigh Manor appears especially alive tonight, all the gas lanterns ablaze. On my way here, I followed the light like a north star through the wildflower field, now a slumbering tangle of crunchy, frost-tinged grass. When the door opens, I expect Mrs. Stark the housekeeper with her stony stare, but instead it’s Miriam flooding the brick stoop in amber warmth.
“You came!” she exclaims, grasping my arm and tugging me into the marble-floored foyer.
I brush snow from my boots before removing my coat and gloves and hanging them on a mahogany coat rack. Through winter-stung eyes, I study Miriam. Her gown is a creamy white embroidered with lace in the same icy blue shade of her eyes. And draped around her swan-like neck are the pearls I had my scullery maid deliver this afternoon.
“If I hadn’t, you would have dragged me here yourself,” I say, still catching my breath from the walk and how beautiful Miri looks in those pearls, just as I knew she would.
“You’re lucky I didn’t,” she teases, touching the necklace. “Shame on you for not giving this to me yourself.”
I blush.
“I have been busy,” I try.
A tense beat.
“With Frederick?” she asks, voice tight.
“Yes,” I say, casting my gaze to the floor. “He called on me this morning. I could not refuse.”
I wait for her to say more, but just as quickly, she brightens, taking my hand and pulling me into the sitting room.
Since her parents took ill and passed away a year ago, this house and everything in it belongs to her, a team of clerks managing her small fortune while she is free to pursue her watercolor painting and impressive doll collection. Despite the loss she suffered, I cannot help but envy her life. When Mother dies, all of the family fortune will go to my younger brother. Marrying Frederick is the only way I’ll have even a portion of what Miriam Everleigh has.
“Sit,” she says, gesturing to the loveseat beside the Christmas tree.
Lost in my head, I didn’t even notice we’d reached the center of the sitting room. I obey, watching her stoop to retrieve a package topped with a silken black bow. She presents the gift with an eager grin.
“What is it?” I ask, taking the box.
She sinks down beside me, electrifyingly close. My skin tingles with her proximity.
“Open it.”
I strain my ears for any telltale footsteps in the upper floors or a clatter of dishes from the kitchen, but the house is silent save for Miriam’s rapid breathing.
“Are we—?” I begin, clutching the package. “Where are the staff this evening?”
“I sent them home,” Miriam says with a sly grin. “Open your present, Cecile.”
With an anticipatory shiver, I slide off the bow and tear open the box.
The doll with my face peers from its wrapping paper womb, all gilded curls and huge brown eyes. Entranced, I lift it from the box, stroking my thumb along its cool, glassy cheek.
“She’s you,” Miriam says, brushing aside a strand of hair caught in my lashes. The tender contact threatens to overtake me like the dense ivy still clinging to the walls of Everleigh Manor.
“I can see that,” I tell her, voice low as I settle deeper into the sofa, training my focus only on the doll and not Miri’s face mere inches from mine.
The doll’s nose is pert with a slight upturn at the tip. Its lips are full and pink. There are freckles, beige pinpricks that appear to have been dabbed on with a single hair in place of a paint brush. It isn’t only that the doll has my hair and eye color. It has been molded and shaped as my precise likeness, down to the little mole high upon its left cheekbone.
Miriam’s smile has a glint of familiar mischief in it. It’s the smile she favored me with the springtime of my eleventh year, the day we met. I’d resolved to run away from home, become a fae creature of the wilds, free from Mother’s biting insults and impossible expectations. With nothing but a stolen wedge of soft white cheese and a stale dinner roll tucked in a kerchief, I set out first thing in the morning, drawn inexorably to the ocean of flowers flanking the forest.
Pink astor, blazing star, butterfly weed. All were known to me from books, my only companions. And in that field, twirling and singing without abandon among the circling bees and dandelion fluff, was a girl. She had a crown of daisies woven into her unbound black hair, the hem of her dress coated in clinging seedlings. And when her eyes found mine, I knew I was exactly where I belonged.
A sanctuary and a certain kind of Hell.
For the wild stirrings Miriam Everleigh elicited in my belly from the moment she took my hand in that field of flowers and dragged me along to our adulthoods. For how in moments like this, enveloped by her earthy scent, tracking the rise and fall of her breathing near enough to match it, I long for something I’m too afraid to name.
“It’s not just any doll, my lovely,” she continues, resting her hand atop mine atop the doll’s lap. My chest hitches as her touch remains, my ribs straining above a dull thrum. That want, that ache. “It is you.”
As I lift a questioning brow at her, the doll’s face flashes in my periphery, the painted slashes of its eyebrows drawing together. There and gone in an instant, leaving nothing amiss on its static features when I regard it full on.
“Are we not too old for playthings?” I ask with a dry swallow, sliding my hand from hers. I busy myself with straightening the sleeves on the doll’s red dress.
Miriam smiles impishly. Her pearl necklace flashes in the firelight, along with her teeth. Silvery strands of tinsel sway in the pungent evergreen among its array of hanging ornaments and baubles. The only decoration Miri asked the staff to arrange.
Every Christmas needs presents, she explained over tea last week. And every present needs a tree to go under.
Christmases in Everleigh Manor were once grand affairs. String quartets, silk gowns and satin ribbons, endless puddings and sweets, an enormous turkey browned and crisp on a banquet table overflowing with garlands of pine and imported citrus fruits. Miri and I lingered in the upstairs nursery with the other children, sneaking cinnamon tarts with buttery crusts that melted on our tongues like the richest unspoken secrets.
This is to be our last Christmas together before I marry Frederick and begin my new life at his townhouse in the city. My stomach twists at the unwelcome thought. By next year, nights like this will be a distant memory.
But tonight, in Miriam’s lavish candle-lit sitting room, the dark windows ensconced with powdery snowfall, we were the only two creatures in existence before the doll joined us. This twin of me. This gift of me.
“It is no toy, Cecile,” Miriam smirks. “And I doubt dolls have ever amused you. I know you much better than that, my lovely.”
Outside, the wind howls, a blizzard forming. I turn the doll this way and that, a tingle edging along my skin where Miriam’s gaze strikes it. She’s right, of course. I never played with dolls as a child. I preferred the magic of my own imagination or the company of a fairy story. Miriam, on the other hand, loved dolls. Collected them from the finest toymakers. Fashioned her own out of twigs and scraps of old dresses. Brushed their hair. Polished their tiny shoes. Whispered over them. Poppets, she called them. Her silent friends.
This doll is as fitting a gift from her as any as my own childhood comes to its end. Next Christmas, I will be a wife. There will be no more clover crowns, no more fairy tales, no more Everleigh Manor.
No more Miriam.
“Enlighten me then,” I say with a forced smile as my throat fills with cotton. Another flicker of movement on the doll’s lips, there and gone. The lantern light catches across its shiny ceramic face. My face. “If not just a toy, then what?”
“Haven’t you been listening? It is you.”
I chuckle, tamping the urge to shift nearer to her on the tufted cushion.
“Miri, please. No riddles. It is late and I must be getting back.”
Miriam leans in, a spill of black hair loosening from its pins. She smells of pine and citrus, potent and sweet. She takes the doll. Whispers across its golden curls. As she does, a warm breeze caresses my cheek—a draft from the fireplace perhaps.
She adopts a strange look. Wolfish. Provocative. The skin pinches between her brows, her jawline rigid, her pale eyes hardening to ice. I blink, a surge of unease carving through my want, but something else, too.
Exhilaration.
Excitement.
Miri could be a goddess of war. An eldritch fairy queen.
“Back to what?” she challenges, her words as cutting as her bared slash of a smile. “That monstrous woman? That complete bore of a fiance? To a future you don’t even want?”
My spine straightens, nostrils flaring open, my heart a wounded bird fluttering behind my ribs. My enchantment ebbs, replaced by confused hurt.
“What are you saying?”
“I speak the truth, Cecile,” Miriam says, softening. “Now be still for me.”
“Miri, what—”
She presses her lips against the doll’s forehead, tender and deliberate, her eyes trained on mine in a meaningful way. I gasp, touching my own forehead, an invisible pressure on my skin.
A trick. An illusion. It must be. This is not real.
“We both know that place is not your home,” she continues, eyes glinting. “You belong here, Cecile. With me.”
When Miriam kisses the doll’s tiny parted lips, I feel it, too. There and gone. A teasing contact, whisper-light.
“Miri…” I breathe, eyes wide. My lungs strain against my corset, unable to draw in enough air. “What is happening?”
“Happy Christmas, my lovely,” she says, her mischievous facade receding at last. Trapping her shapely bottom lip beneath her teeth, she lifts the doll’s skirts. Brushes her finger along its polished white leg.
I shiver at the contact across my own calf.
“How?” I pant. “Miri—”
She shushes me, gathering the doll’s dress about its stuffed fabric waist. When she presses into the smooth, formless place between the doll’s legs, I cry out, back arching against the embroidered loveseat. She rubs in a tight semicircle, her predatory smile never wavering.
This is witchcraft. This is evil. This is…perfection.
Through the hazy cloud of my horrified astonishment, Miriam’s scent chokes me, and God help me, I want it to. I want all of her. Her flesh on my flesh. Her touch on me. Not that accursed doll, but me and—
No. For the sake of us both, I must be stronger than this.
You’re so good, Ceci, Miriam used to tell me. My unfailing moral compass.
Swallowing my pleasurable moans, I squeeze my legs shut, fighting against the sensation, against her, but she’s relentless. I must remember who I am, that it is not too late, that I can still save us both.
“Stop,” I choke, wringing my fingers through my skirts, a hot flush gathering in my chest and flooding into my face. “Miri, please. Stop this.”
“Cecile,” Miriam whispers over the doll, never once easing up on her touches. “My Cecile.”
Heart thundering, fighting against my combined ecstasy and shame, I snatch the doll from her, clutching it to my chest. I shuffle away until my back strikes the sofa’s armrest.
“What do you think you’re doing?” I snap through labored breaths.
“It’s not a sin if I don’t touch you,” she says, her smile unfaltering.
I squeeze the doll harder, stroking its hair. I don’t register my own touches as I did Miriam’s. My dearest friend’s violating—yet so intoxicating—touches. Shadows lengthen over us as the blizzard rages outside. In the guttering firelight, she is beautiful in the way that all frightening things are. Angular. Sharp. Forbidden.
“Have you ever been touched that way before, my lovely?” she continues, edging closer until her face hovers over mine. “Has Frederick even kissed you?”
My blush deepens. It doesn’t matter what I think of Frederick now. One day, he and I will come to love each other in the way that Miriam and I cannot because she is a woman and I am a woman and if Mother ever found out about tonight—
“I’m going now,” I manage, cradling the doll as if it’s my very soul. “Please, Miri. I will forget this night and I beg you to do the same.” With shaking hands, I shove the doll into her chest, rebuking her gift. “Whatever trick this is, whatever conjurer’s charm you’ve employed, remove it. Take this horrid thing back. I…” A sting behind my eyes, a knot trapped in my throat. “I do not desire you, Miriam.”
She blinks those pale eyes at the doll in her hands. Her shoulders hitch. She hefts a sigh. The blizzard rages, rattling the windows in their panes. The Christmas tree rustles. At our feet, the cavernous innards of the package the doll arrived in is an open mouth framed by jagged paper teeth.
“You may lie to yourself, but you cannot lie to me,” she says, tossing the doll on the cushion behind her. My own body registers the contact as a breathtaking jolt across my back. Miriam clasps my hands in hers, vulnerable in a way I’ve never seen her before. Her grip is strong, grinding my knuckles together. Her pearls clack against her breastplate as her eyes latch onto mine.
“Let me free you, Cecile. Take care of you as when we were children. He cannot make you happy like I will. He is just another cage. Another jailer, just like your mother. Like my parents were.” Her grip tightens. “But I freed myself from them and I can do the same for you. You have only but to ask.”
Trembling, I tear loose from Miriam and stand, heeled boots sinking in the floral rug. She rises with me, that wildness I always admired visible in every facet of her diamond eyes and angular cheekbones. Whatever cryptic implication she just confessed to regarding her parents’ demise, I do not wish to hear it. She is a sorceress, an agent of the devil on this most holy night and she would drag me with her into his clutches. I never knew this woman at all.
“No, Miri,” I plead, twisting toward the grand foyer. “I’m leaving now. When you’ve come to your senses, you’ll—”
I cry out when she yanks me by my wrist and tosses me to the loveseat. The doll bounces in my wake just before she takes it into her arms like an errant child. Miriam’s chest rises and falls, twin rivers carving down each rosy cheek.
“Admit it,” she says, her voice hushed, inflectionless. Without preamble, she winds her fingers into the doll’s golden curls and rips several strands loose.
I cry out, my scalp aflame. Wisps of golden thread flutter past my eyes. My own hair, torn from the root. My eyes burn with unshed tears, a scream caught in my chest.
“Admit that you love me,” Miriam presses, digging her nails into the doll’s soft belly. I groan at the sensation of dull blades jabbing my skin, bruising and punishing.
“Miriam,” I cry, doubled over, hugging myself. “Don’t—”
“Stop denying us!” Miriam shrieks, her composure dropping like a heavy curtain at the opera we attended last week and silently snickered the entire way through. This is not that woman. This is not my Miri.
Shuddering, chest hitching, I dart toward the foyer, storm be damned. I need to leave this place, put as much distance between myself and her crazed obsession as I can before—
I hear the shatter before I feel it. A dropped dinner plate. A lilting crack. I fall, striking my head on the stone hearth before the fire. My vision wavers with each of Miriam’s steps until she stands over me, the doll in one hand and its porcelain foot in the other. With a dazed whimper, I scan the length of my body and release a ragged mewl at what I find.
My ankle is a perfect twin of the doll’s. Bloodless. Jagged edges. My foot rests several inches away inside my lace-up boot, only instead of meat and muscle surrounding a bone core, the limb is hollow. Porcelain. A network of black cracks spiderweb up my calf, ceramic giving way to living tissue.
Miriam kneels beside me, triumphant and smug as if she won yet another round of croquet or outlasted me in a game of hide-and-seek. Even as children, she always won. This time is no different. She will have her way. She always gets her way.
“Don’t be afraid, my lovely,” she says. “You can be repaired. This can all be fixed, you’ll see.”
“Miri…” I moan, stemming the blood flowing on my scalp from striking the stone hearth. I lift my deformed leg, shuddering at the loss of feeling where my foot once was. Where there should be pain, there is only a dull nothing, heavy as clay. My best friend’s eyes are as lifeless as the doll she holds as both stare down at me. She lays the doll’s castaway foot on the side table before regarding me again.
“Tell the truth,” Miriam says, her voice achingly tender as she brushes a sweaty strand of hair from my eyes. “You love me, Cecile. You always have.”
I choke around a sob. She’s hurt me. Shattered me.
But God, how I have awoken in the loneliest nights from sweet dreams of her lips on mine, her long cool fingers sliding through my hair, her laughter across my skin. How I have tucked those shameful, beautiful fantasies down deep where no one can find them, least of all myself. Even now, I would welcome her love, twisted and cruel as she’s proven it to be.
“Say it,” she urges above my whimpering. “Say it and I will see to it that no one ever hurts you again.”
“You’re hurting me, Miri,” I say. “Please. Do not do this.”
“I am saving you,” she says, her voice steady and certain. “You and I… We are inevitable. We always have been. This is my gift to you, Cecile. Admit your truth and we can begin our lives. Together.”
“It sounds beautiful, Miri,” I whisper, dizzied by converging thoughts of Mother’s fury, Miriam’s savagery, and the condemnation of a world that will never condone the life Miri and I could have shared. What she is proposing is impossible. She is devastation, this incandescent flame of a woman before me. My most treasured friend. My ruin.
“It will be, my lovely,” says Miriam, pulling me into her lap. I rest my cheek against her stomach, inhaling her as she holds me against the pain she caused. The doll’s curls tickle my face, its expression heartbreakingly sad. My mirror. My gift.
“Miriam,” I say, closing my eyes. “Miriam…”
“Yes,” she says with feeling. “Yes, I’m here. I will always be here.”
Hot tears in my eyes, I bundle the front of her dress in my fist and drag her face to mine. I part her lips with my tongue, tasting her. She groans into my mouth, our salty tears mingling as we kiss our collected pain away, banish the world and its barriers to places so far off they can never trap us again.
“Thank you, Miri,” I whisper. My friend rattles out a sigh as my fingers grasp the doll’s arm. “I will always love you.”
With her eyes trained on mine, her smile cast in all the radiance of the spring sunshine over the wildflower fields in which we played, I lift the doll and dash her porcelain face against the ground.
Three winters come and go. We share her canopy bed, floor-to-ceiling shelves of dolls watching over us while we sleep. A sea of baked clay, fabric, glass, wax, and gleaming eyes of all shapes and sizes. Miriam’s lifelong collection. Most are comfortingly silent and inanimate, but sometimes, I can hear the others. Close-mouthed moans, wordless pleas.
My body has never once touched that pile. I am not like the others, that lifeless throng. I am singular. Miri’s finest work. We are never apart, she and I. As promised, she has saved me. Repaired me. Protected me. Her favorite toy. She spares hardly a glance at the others anymore. Her collection stopped with me.
Tonight, she has moved me into our sitting room beneath the light of the immense evergreen tree and its usual adornments. She folds my immobile hands in my lap, the cracks in my glossy skin faint as gossamer lace. She has dressed me in a fine green gown, polished my face with rose water, and draped emeralds around my neck.
“Happy Christmas, my lovely,” she says, her lips warm against a deep rift marring the surface of my cheek. Humming beneath her breath, she takes up a brush and glides its bristles through my golden hair. With a shifting sound of stone sliding against stone, I close my eyes. My heart beats, the meaty organ pumping like a whisper beneath my ceramic exterior.
A joyous bead of moisture gathers at the corner of my glass eye and vanishes into my vast network of fractures before Miri can see it.
Happy Christmas, my Miri.
I will always love you.
The End.